After an initial dazzlement with artist Jorge Gamboa’s arresting plastic bag iceberg image on the cover of National Geographic —we really thought it was an iceberg at first —, a hue and cry when up on Twitter accusing the artist and National Geographic of ripping off the idea from a) Matus Bence’s 2015 ad campaign for Tesco or b) stock images on Getty.

Matus Bence and National Geographic

One level-headed person wondered if it was in fact a case of Multiple Discovery (also known as Simultaneous Invention), the idea that discoveries and inventions are often made independently and more or less simultaneously by multiple people. (Wikipedia has a long list of Multiple Discoveries spanning back to the 3rd century BC.)

Getty Images

I experienced this numerous times when I was a chef and then food writer. After a friend brought me some then-unknown white chocolate from Europe 40 or so years ago, I was sure I was unique (and brilliant) in discovering its affinity with eau to vie de framboise, a clear, fragrant alcohol distilled from raspberries, which I used to make White Chocolate Truffles with Hazelnuts and Framboise. Not long after, I heard of a similar flavor paring by a chef on the West Coast.

I had only just learned of white chocolate and hadn’t seen it written about in the food pages yet. Yet the West Coast chef and I both “discovered” the affinity of white chocolate with framboise at the same time, although our creations were quite different, each forged by our unique sensibility. Both were sparked, I believe, by the white chocolate itself and by the general food world zeitgeist. We were both “listening” to the material as artist Anni Albers described:

Sally Schneider

The spontaneous generation of ideas among very different people in different places, joined only by being in the same time, makes us realize, once again, our mysteriously connected we all are.

If you’ve found illumination, joy, or inspiration in this post, please consider supporting Improvised Life. It only takes a minute to make a secure donation that helps pay our many costs. A little goes a long way towards helping Improvised Life continue to live ad-free in the world.

Support Improvised Life ♥

3 replies on “Multiple Discovery is Not Plagiarism, But a Reflection of How Connected We Secretly Are

  1. 100 Monkey syndrome! Yes, I love life’s little mysteries and serendipities.

  2. Sally, I still can’t seem to access your web site because the reset password flashes on so fast I can’t
    see it. I would gladly send you far more than you ask because I enjoy the Improvised Life so much.
    Hate to not see it.

  3. Hi Barbara, This is a true mystery so I am hoping my tech person will solve it. Keep me posted!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *